Here’s how the 2020 Democrats differ on health care
designer491/iStock(WASHINGTON) — Amid debate over rising medical costs, surprise hospital bills and high prescription drug prices, health care remains a top priority for voters in the 2020 presidential election.
Here are the candidates who have put out proposals so far and what we know about those who have yet to do so. The list doesn’t include every Democratic candidate, but highlights candidates who have significant positions or experience that sets them apart.
Where Democrats stand on a single payer system that eliminates private insurance
The debate on “Medicare for All”, which would overhaul the nations’s current health care system, has begun to sow division in the 2020 field.
According to Politifact, eliminating the private insurance market would “shake up nearly a fifth of the nation’s economy.”
Some candidates are rallying behind the concept, others are against it and some have suggested forming a hybrid system that would call for universal health care while at the same time allowing people to chose private insurance if they want it.
Former Vice President Joe Biden released a plan in July that his campaign said would make the Affordable Care Act easier to navigate with more choices for Americans.
The plan would expand upon the Affordable Care Act passed under the Obama-Biden administration and provide a public, government-run insurance option for consumers to purchase on the existing exchanges with the goal on keeping costs down and expanding access for patients to buy into. This proposal differs from a Medicare for All system that several of Biden’s 2020 rivals advocate for — a contrast the former vice president has already started to draw on the campaign trail.
“We should not be starting from scratch. We should be building from what we have. There is no time to wait. And I that’s why I think, what I’m proposing — and we can do it — is to keep Obamacare, restore the cuts that have been made, and add a public option,” Biden said during an event in Dover, New Hampshire, on Friday. “If they like their employer-based insurance, you get to keep it. The fact of the matter is, all the other proposals make you — you lose it. Period.”
The Biden campaign estimates that the plan will cost $750 billion over 10 years. Senior advisers said Biden would rescind President Donald Trump’s tax cuts for the wealthy, raise the maximum tax bracket to 39% and get rid of the capital gains tax loophole for wealthy families with incomes greater than $1 million a year in order to cover the hefty price tag.
Shortly after his announcement, Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., countered Biden via Twitter.
“I fought to improve and pass Obamacare. I traveled all over the country to fight the repeal of Obamacare,” Sanders wrote. “But I will not be deterred from ending the corporate greed that creates dysfunction in our health care system. We must pass Medicare for All.”
In April, Sanders again introduced his signature health care legislation, which if passed and signed into law, would provide government-run, Medicare-style health insurance for all Americans and outlaw most duplicative private insurance in the process.
“The Medicare for All Act will provide comprehensive health care to every man, woman and child in our country without out of pocket expenses. No more insurance premiums, deductibles or co-payments. Further, this bill improves Medicare coverage to include dental, hearing and vision care,” Sanders’ team wrote in a summary of the bill distributed ahead of a press conference on Capitol Hill.
Sanders has introduced the bill several times in the last decade, but the latest version is more sweeping. It now calls for expanded coverage to include and pay for long-term care, as well as no co-pays for doctors visits.
One study last year from the Mercatus Center at George Mason University estimated that Sanders’ legislation could cost the federal government more than $32 trillion dollars over 10 years.
His plan offers few concrete deals on how to pay for the expanded federal system, but in the past the senator has backed significantly higher income taxes for wealthy Americans and businesses in the country.
Fellow 2020 Democratic presidential candidates Sens. Cory Booker, Elizabeth Warren, Kamala Harris and Kirsten Gillibrand have signed on as cosponsors for Sanders’ Medicare-for-all bill in the Senate.
While Harris is a supporter of Sanders’ legislation, his campaign says the plan that she released Monday stops short of what the Vermont senator envisions for Americans.
The key distinction between the two senators’ plans is that Harris still sees the private system playing a role. Her plan is more of a hybrid health insurance system that allows private companies to be able to offer health insurance plans within the Medicare system for consumers.
Harris’ plan also calls for a 10 year transition to a single-payer system while Sanders plan calls for four years.
Harris also pointed out that she views Sanders plan as too tough on the middle-class. She said that she doesn’t like Sanders’ options to tax households making above $29,000 an additional 4% income-based premium. Instead, she is proposing to exempt households making below $100,000, along with a higher income threshold for middle-class families living in high-cost areas.
Sanders’ campaign manager Faiz Shakir criticized Harris’ plan saying it centers on Medicare privatization, insurance executives and introducing more corporate greed and profiteering into the Medicare system.“Call it anything you want, but you can’t call this plan Medicare for All.”
Biden’s campaign also criticized the plan.
“This new, have-it-every-which-way approach pushes the extremely challenging implementation of the Medicare for All part of this plan ten years into the future, meaning it would not occur on the watch of even a two-term administration,” Kate Bedingfield, a Biden deputy campaign manager, said in a statement. “The result? A Bernie Sanders-lite Medicare for All and a refusal to be straight with the American middle class, who would have a large tax increase forced on them with this plan.”
Tricia Neuman, a senior vice president for the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation and director of the Medicare policy program told the New York Times that “The appeal of private Medicare Advantage-type plans may boil down to whether the plans offer better benefits, with lower costs, and what the provider networks look like. So, a key question is how insurers will be able to differentiate themselves from the public program.”
During the first presidential debate, Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., vocalized her support for a hybrid plan which allows uninsured Americans to sign up for a public plan. The public option plans would essentially allow individuals to choose between public insurance plan, like Medicare or Medicaid, or a private insurance plan.
“It’s something Barack Obama wanted to do, which is a public option,” Klobuchar said. “I’m concerned about kicking half of America off their health insurance.”
Former Rep. Beto O’Rourke echoed a similar sentiment saying that he would “preserve choice” by not eliminating private insurance.
Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, Sen. Julian Castro, Andrew Yang, Michael Bennet, John Delaney and Marianne Williamson have also expressed that they would support private insurance playing some role in the health care system.
An issue that affects candidates and voters nationwide
Candidates supporting a complete overhaul of the health care system might have a tough time winning over voters on this issue. According to a recent Gallup poll, most Americans are happy with their current health coverage.
The poll found that 69% of Americans rate the coverage and 80% rate the quality of the health care they personally receive as “excellent” or “good.”
However, the same poll found that only 34% of Americans view health care coverage in the U.S. in general as positive.
In an ABC News/Washington Post poll released in April, 19% of Americans said that health care is one of the most important issues when voting for president in the 2020 election. Among leaned Democrats, health care ranked as the most important issue with voters, with 29% responding.
The poll also found that Americans, by a 17-point margin, say President Donald Trump’s handling of health care makes them more likely to oppose than support him for a second term.
Copyright © 2019, ABC Radio. All rights reserved.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.