Coronavirus is pushing US child care industry to brink of collapse: Advocates
ABC NewsBy KAREN TRAVERS and JANET WEINSTEIN, ABC News
(NEW YORK) — Diana Limongi says she is heartbroken.
“So I am here at my daughter’s daycare, and that’s it. You know, they’re closing,” Limongi said as she packed up her 3-year-old daughter’s things from her now-closed child care center. “It’s all empty. A beautiful space and both my kids went here. So I’m really, really sad.”
Limongi and many working parents are learning firsthand a tough reality — the coronavirus pandemic is pushing the nation’s child care industry to the brink of collapse.
This is a top concern for millions of working parents. If you have to go back to the office and your child care center is closed, what do you do? Experts say this is a key piece to the puzzle to reopening the U.S. economy.
“Child care is in a crisis moment right now,” said Myra Jones Taylor, chief policy officer at Zero to Three, a nonprofit organization that focuses on the developmental needs of babies and toddlers.
Nationwide, nearly half of child care providers completely closed their facilities during the COVID-19 shutdowns, according to a survey by the National Association for the Education of Young Children.
Of those that stayed open, 85% are operating with less than half of their usual child enrollment.
The outlook for the industry is grim: an analysis by the Center for American Progress found that roughly half of U.S. child care capacity is at risk of disappearing.
“There is no way that the economy will be able to open completely without child care being fully supported and stable,” Taylor told ABC News.
“People talk about the airlines industry. They talk about restaurants. They talk about meat processing plants. But they don’t talk about all the people who go to work every day and need child care,” said Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash.
The $2 trillion CARES act, a federal COVID-19 relief package, included nearly $60 billion for the airline industry, but just $3.5 billion was set aside for child care providers.
Murray told ABC News that is not good enough.
“Most of (child care providers) are saying we can’t survive, we can’t reopen, we can’t keep going without additional funding,” Murray said.
Calling herself the only former preschool teacher in the U.S. Senate, Murray introduced legislation to put $50 billion in federal funding toward the child care industry.
“I’m just saying to my fellow colleagues, just ask any friend, do you have kids? What is their biggest issue right now? And this is it,” she said.
Child care centers are expensive to operate. Experts say they are already working around very thin margins, some often taking in just enough to cover their operating costs. Most do not have a rainy day fund for a crisis like this. Now throw in the additional costs of the new normal in the coronavirus pandemic: personal protective equipment, sanitizer, deep cleanings.
Parents like Limongi, who now find themselves scrambling for child care, say the federal government needs to step up and help working families.
“We don’t have child care. We can’t work. It’s as simple as that,” she said.
Circle Time is a child care center in Kensington, Maryland. It has stayed open during the COVID-19 shutdowns because it serves essential workers. But their enrollment went from a full enrollment of 78 children to — at one point — just nine kids.
Owner Gigi Serrano says a key reason she can stay afloat: every family paid full tuition for April and some are still paying half, even if their children are at home.
“We sent out an e-mail just asking parents to pay what they could. To hold their spot if they weren’t coming in,” Serrano told ABC. “Again, several of our families were incredible. A few even paid extra. And I feel like that was to help the families that maybe couldn’t contribute as much.”
Melissa Joy’s two sons went back to Circle Time after spending three months at home. She says she has had a lot of discussions with other parents about how to support the center.
“They’ve always been there for us. We try to be there for them,” Joy said.
Serrano says so far she has not been forced to lay off any staff, crediting a loan she received through the federal government’s paycheck protection program.
But the Circle Time staff is more fortunate than most — roughly 1/3 of child care workers have been laid off since March, according to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
One of those workers impacted is Martha Rodriquez who worked as a bilingual instructional assistant at a pre school in Renton, Washington.
“You know, I’m not sure if I’m going to back to work really soon because I’m not an essential, essential person in the classroom,” Rodriquez said.
More than 90% of the nation’s 1.2 million child care workers are women. Some experts say that is a key reason the industry is undervalued and taken for granted.
“It is something that people just assume will always be there,” said Katie Hamm, the vice president for early childhood policy at the Center for American Progress.
History has shown that it sometimes takes a crisis to force Washington to rethink its priorities.
“I think we have been ambivalent about child care in this country for so long. We cannot do that anymore. We have to treat this like a public good,” said Zero to Three’s Taylor.
Serrano, the owner of Circle Time in Maryland, said she is feeling OK right now, but wonders how long her business can hang on without help.
“We’ll probably be good until about September. But beyond that, it’s really just going to depend,” she said. “How many of our families are still able to work? How many of them are still able to contribute to holding a spot?”
“This is a long time,” she added. “It’s a long time to ask families to contribute when there’s really no actual end date.”
Copyright © 2020, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.